While most of us love experimenting with new beauty and skin-care products every once in a while, there’s something particularly comforting about the tried and true products that never let us down—especially when they’re at price points that don’t give us sticker shock.
Today we’re sharing eleven of the drugstore beauty products our team loves that have stood the test of time.
These products range in price from $6 on the low end to $22 on the high end—they get the job done and they’re relatively affordable to boot. We hope you find these recommendations helpful!
Makeup Products
1. L’Oreal Infallible Flash Cat Eye Waterproof Eyeliner
Recommended by: Kate, Founder & Creative Director
$9
In Kate’s words, “This eyeliner lasts forever and has a super-fine tip that allows for a lot of control. It goes on smoothly every time and doesn’t stay wet for too long. I used to always get smudges on my eyelids from eyeliner but never with this product!”
2. Honest Beauty Extreme Length Mascara + Lash Primer
Recommended by: Greta, Shop W&D Fulfillment Manager
$20
This product is a convenient 2-in-1 mascara and primer that boosts both lash volume and length. The product goes on smoothly with no clumps in sight.
3. Maybelline Great Lash Mascara
Recommended by: Erin, New Business Director
$6
Whether or not we’ve tried it ourselves, chances are we’re all familiar with the look of this classic pink mascara tube. As Erin says, “This product has got a cult following for a reason. When possible, I try to find it in the ‘Blackest Black’ color.”
4. Pixi LipGlow
Recommended by: Kate
$14
Per Kate, “This is my favorite sheer lipstick. It goes on smoothly and gives an instantly polished look without feeling too sticky or caked on. I prefer the ruby color because I can build it to the intensity I prefer given my mood that day.”
5. Burt’s Bees Beeswax Lip Balm 2-Pack
Recommended by: Erin
$6.50
I’d be willing to take a bet that the vast majority of us have tried this classic lip balm at one point or another. It’s moisturizing and refreshingly minty and, as Erin says, “It’s an easy go-to I’ve been using for probably fifteen years.”
Skin-Care Products
6. Thayers Witch Hazel Alcohol-Free Toner
Recommended by: Bridgette, Brand Director & Greta
$11
Per Bridgette, “My regular nighttime routine includes a final clean with toning. I’m always disgusted/fascinated by how much YUCK is removed with the toner even after I’ve already washed my face.”
7. Bliss Makeup Melt Dry/Wet Gentle Jelly Cleanser
Recommended by: Bridgette
$9
According to Bridgette, “I fell in love with the Glossier Milky Jelly Cleanser and its lightweight cleansing ability, but I wasn’t savvy enough to remember to reorder it before it ran out. I found a great alternative in Bliss Makeup Melt. It still feels lightweight and works just as well.”
8. Versed Press Restart Gentle Retinol Serum
Recommended by: Carolyn, Graphic Designer
$22
According to Carolyn, “This product has done the MOST to clear up my skin. There’s more I could say about it but basically I would tell anyone dealing with acne to try it. Honestly, I kind of panic when I run out. 
9. Honest Beauty Gentle Konjac Sponge
Recommended by: Bridgette
$10
As Bridgette puts it, “I LOVE a good, deep exfoliation, but I know that it’s not always the best for your skin. I like using the Gentle Konjac Sponge to get the feeling of scrubbing without actually taking a layer of skin off my face. I use the sponge in conjunction with the Bliss Makeup Melt.”
Body Products
10. Jergens Hand & Body Lotion
Recommended by: Nancy, Executive Assistant
$8
This body lotion has remained a favorite of Nancy’s for years. It’s moisturizing, has a lovely scent (that isn’t too overpowering), and it’s pretty hard to beat that sweet, sweet price point.
11. Native Coconut & Vanilla Deodorant
Recommended by: Jackie
$13
This deodorant and I are in a long-term relationship. I’ve tried other “natural” deodorants that my body eventually started to reject (translation: I smelled) but I’ve used this one for years and that hasn’t happened. It smells amazing and works like a charm.
Editor’s Note: This article contains affiliate links. Wit & Delight uses affiliate links as a source for revenue to fund operations of the business. Have a question or want to learn more about how we use affiliate links? Shoot us an email.
Jackie is the editorial director at Wit & Delight. In her spare time, you can find her running around the lakes of Minneapolis, grabbing a bite at a local restaurant, or recharging at home. Find more info at jackiesaffert.com and follow her on Instagram @jackiesaffert.
BY Jackie Saffert - August 27, 2020
Most-read posts:
Did you know W&D now has a resource library of Printable Art, Templates, Freebies, and more?
take me there
Get Our Best W&D Resources
for designing a life well-lived
Thank you for being here. For being open to enjoying life’s simple pleasures and looking inward to understand yourself, your neighbors, and your fellow humans! I’m looking forward to chatting with you.
Hi, I'm Kate. Welcome to my happy place.
Really excellent and helpful information. We appreciate you sharing this insightful information with us. Send us updates in the manner described.